九記牛腩一杯熱水$16?網民憑餐牌一細節估另有所指 店方揭真相|Juicy叮
2023-10-25 10:46
中環名店「牛記牛腩」的餐牌,近日被網民發現一杯熱水標價16元,引發熱議,有人指收費不合理,但有人則指明碼實價沒有問題,不過,有細心網民憑餐牌一細節估另有真相。
牛記牛腩一杯熱水$16 真相疑是...↓↓↓↓
![中環名店「牛記牛腩」的餐牌,近日被網民發現一杯熱水標價16元,引發熱議。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/e13161b1268dec85854aaecfa0b4c856/2023-10/7_2_22.png)
![該網民在「香港茶餐廳及美食關注組」FB專頁發帖,帖文中附有牛記牛腩懸掛店內的餐牌。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/f99d1f2fa567e9d8de762773c3b1ca35/2023-10/8_1_14.png)
![該網民在「香港茶餐廳及美食關注組」FB專頁發帖,帖文中附有牛記牛腩懸掛店內的餐牌。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/304a773d9b6539e91d4cd596438c18bc/2023-10/49_3.jpg)
![餐牌標明一杯熱水,收費16元,與汽水同價。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/0ef8762f0570c691723d01e549094227/2023-10/53_3.jpg)
![餐牌標明一杯熱水,收費16元,與汽水同價。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/5053f31767d50878e93b841ae7e46c57/2023-10/9_46.png)
![樓主在帖文中批評:「一杯熱水要16蚊,不如淨係賣熱水咪得囉,一定賺得多過依家。」](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/f76f63a1abbeead48ecf0c711a6d2833/2023-10/10_1_23.png)
![帖文一出引發熱議,有網民批評收費離譜。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/e13f388832ba23b0595bfedcf3da95e1/2023-10/11_0_34.png)
![有網民批評收費離譜。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/034565c8ef67d907b25836b7cdbf6a3b/2023-10/2023-10-25_095334.jpg)
![有網民批評收費離譜。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/2cf5de13a981e9e04fe1b8f561ec10ba/2023-10/2023-10-25_095523.jpg)
![有網民批評收費離譜。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/c68907654978a4e4d07045c40b949592/2023-10/2023-10-25_101849.jpg)
![但有網民則認為明碼實價,並無不妥。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/88ca6a95bb07f6e552287eeca136d138/2023-10/12_0_26.png)
![有網民則認為明碼實價,並無不妥。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/b1c14f57701361e37e4a887bc21469e2/2023-10/2023-10-25_095347.jpg)
![有網民則認為明碼實價,並無不妥。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/2af7f706294144ac39370f65c21edd69/2023-10/2023-10-25_095417.jpg)
![有網民則認為明碼實價,並無不妥。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/6b77f3c4e65c8a1f1004e0eaf0d28347/2023-10/2023-10-25_095530.jpg)
![不過,部分細心網民發現餐牌中的熱水,與汽水及啤酒同列,很有可能是指樽裝礦泉水。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/d2cab25d93c3a3dc62db30c0e24dc553/2023-10/13_0_22.png)
![網民指很有可能是指樽裝礦泉水。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/a7fca71f3a4208b3d62b5a94797edc9c/2023-10/2023-10-25_101846.jpg)
![網民指很有可能是指樽裝礦泉水。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/1ab9edfc0e82889c5c9d7a80b48375d7/2023-10/2023-10-25_091013.jpg)
![網民指很有可能是指樽裝礦泉水。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/c4370bdc498d7e0cbe75abdcc88619d1/2023-10/2023-10-25_101910.jpg)
![網民指很有可能是指樽裝礦泉水。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/e48226665cc0bd5790f5ff2dbbc14a0c/2023-10/2023-10-25_101941.jpg)
![不過,有網民則質疑此講法,「餐牌標明熱水,點可能有『熱』嘅樽裝水?」](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/b05bcdd28ee8560c786cab8943f28742/2023-10/14_0_22.png)
![有網民仍質疑此講法](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/e584f9ec3f09cb6e6f350eed6eef780b/2023-10/2023-10-25_105206.jpg)
![有網民仍質疑此講法](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/1a15575410541227d1939aac165bb4dc/2023-10/2023-10-25_105105.jpg)
![《星島頭條》記者以顧客身份向店家查詢,獲告知$16元的「熱水」,是指樽裝礦泉水。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/e2a6188b5cce5db9cae2119daebd3357/2023-10/77_9.png)
有網民近日在「香港茶餐廳及美食關注組」FB專頁發帖,帖文中附有牛記牛腩懸掛店內的餐牌,見到一杯熱水,收費16元,竟與汽水同價。
樓主在帖文中批評:「一杯熱水要16蚊,不如淨係賣熱水咪得囉,一定賺得多過依家。」
帖文一出引發熱議,有網民批評收費離譜:「好離譜,好反感!客人入去飯,俾杯水都好應該啦,呢啲餐廳我一世都唔會幫襯。」「難怪D人離港消費!」
網民:明碼實價 有乜問題?
但有網民則認為明碼實價,並無不妥,「其實水費,人工,鋪租 要俾錢!佢明碼實價又冇騙人,有乜問題?」
「明碼實價有咩問題?覺得貴唔叫咪得囉。」「一佰蚊杯都冇問題,反正根本冇人齋叫熱水。」「有人逼你一定要飲,㗎。」
不過,部分細心網民從餐牌發現端倪,「水,16蚊,搞清楚係乜水先?有沒有去實地審查一下?」
有網民發現餐牌中的熱水,與汽水及啤酒同列,很有可能是指樽裝礦泉水,不過,有網民則質疑此講法,「餐牌標明熱水,點可能有『熱』嘅樽裝水?」【究竟熱水是否即樽裝水?分析詳見上列圖輯↑↑↑↑】
《星島頭條》記者以顧客身份向店方查詢,獲告知$16元的「熱水」,是指樽裝礦泉水。
同場加映:九記大戰小紅書!內地女拍片爆九記牛腩阿姐鬧人↓↓↓↓
![有內地網民拍片放上小紅書,爆料指九記牛腩阿姐跟客人對罵。網民反應兩極,更有人將事件形容為「九記大戰小紅書」,支持九記牛腩將更多客人鬧走,好讓人龍得以減短。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/447ccb0534f9540840b2286feeef4ec6/2023-10/WhatsApp_Image_2023-06-01_at_11_35_58_AM.jpeg)
![是次鬧人片段在小紅書上已經找不到原帖文,但片段被網民轉載至Facebook香港牛雜關注組。(圖片來源:Facebook@Egak Tam)](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/decf40e33cdae1db8c53c4e5e7762d0f/2023-06/WhatsApp%20Image%202023-06-01%20at%2011.45.28%20AM.jpeg)
![九記牛腩阿姐表情動作逐個捉。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/95bc4c97772c415a8e7a5e42039cb5b5/2023-06/WhatsApp%20Image%202023-06-01%20at%2011.44.55%20AM.jpeg)
![阿姐曾激動指著鏡頭,表情肉緊。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/747b27e6155da5e9a58c8d0b864a4c6f/2023-06/WhatsApp%20Image%202023-06-01%20at%2011.44.31%20AM_0.jpeg)
![根據片段所見,最初拍攝者站在九記牛腩門外,把鏡頭對準正在店內收銀處吃麵的阿姐。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/0cdd8f2e7c2723f8591c7b30a8629e16/2023-06/WhatsApp%20Image%202023-06-01%20at%2011.44.15%20AM_0.jpeg)
![阿姐見狀回應:「呀,上網鬧多啲啦!」](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/c84045557a77943494dee5722cd519f8/2023-06/WhatsApp%20Image%202023-06-01%20at%2011.43.42%20AM_0.jpeg)
![之後便淡定低頭吃麵,嘗試無視事主。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/599aa0b6e20e60921192660ca9e89a70/2023-06/WhatsApp%20Image%202023-06-01%20at%2011.43.24%20AM_0.jpeg)
![而內地女食客繼續以「半鹹淡」廣東話嘗試與阿姐理論,旁邊員工和食客不為所動。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/b7ecd7c0c8180e41755b5df9c3072b1c/2023-06/WhatsApp%20Image%202023-06-01%20at%2011.43.08%20AM_0.jpeg)
![阿姐一邊食麵一邊「迎戰」內地女食客。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/0e48ac064a7e4439bbf3bb4b021b9bf2/2023-06/WhatsApp%20Image%202023-06-01%20at%2011.42.36%20AM_0.jpeg)
![據原帖文內容描述,內地女食客投訴指在結帳時阿姐「多謝都無一句」,便引起罵戰。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/9ae59bac7fc7181bea0d1abcec4e7397/2023-06/WhatsApp%20Image%202023-06-01%20at%2011.42.21%20AM_0.jpeg)
![阿姐表情有時無奈。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/069c6fa9464f7cfe8fb7a2d639057d64/2023-06/WhatsApp%20Image%202023-06-01%20at%2011.42.07%20AM_0.jpeg)
![阿姐表情有時激動。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/ead5e6fc34adc82cb040e2f3aa7e4b84/2023-06/WhatsApp%20Image%202023-06-01%20at%2011.41.47%20AM_0.jpeg)
![惟片段中只聽見二人對罵,未能確實罵戰因由。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/8b10712acb25eb6ee93f5b63aea6b4df/2023-06/WhatsApp%20Image%202023-06-01%20at%2011.41.28%20AM_0.jpeg)
![阿姐鬧得勞氣,內地女食客叫阿姐唔好勞氣。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/d38793a64654684a1d85406511ac71ec/2023-06/WhatsApp%20Image%202023-06-01%20at%2011.41.13%20AM_0.jpeg)
![阿姐鬧得勞氣,內地女食客叫阿姐唔好勞氣。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/70d00a43c87d137e8e7737589dc66cd4/2023-06/WhatsApp%20Image%202023-06-01%20at%2011.40.58%20AM_0.jpeg)
![連食客到收銀處付款都不為所動。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/d7363d0b97915bd46b7a5ea5e58e0496/2023-06/WhatsApp%20Image%202023-06-01%20at%2011.38.37%20AM_0.jpeg)
同場加映:九記牛腩人龍再現 內地女狠批3宗罪「千萬別去」↓↓↓↓
![近日就有內地遊客光顧九記牛腩後,食到一肚氣,在社交媒體圖文並茂鬧爆九記牛腩,叫同胞「千萬別去」。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/3bee74ecb9640294bfa16006ecef73d6/2023-10/20230221_lifestyle_noodles.png)
![內地女怒控九記牛腩3宗罪](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/547f3b194535446ea84632f92ef5a51d/2023-02/1_0_86.png)
![中環九記牛腩是香港數一數二的牛腩名店。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/5cc37b8e9a39d24c0e47e5386e557608/2023-02/2_0_65.png)
![上湯牛腩及咖喱牛腩都是九記名物。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/1d75d29eb4f66b0d9963349cfd690f61/2023-02/3_0_64.png)
![九記由以往的鐵皮檔,變成今天的自置商舖。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/bee4f54528e5ef3cfeb25257302b0880/2023-02/4_0_67.png)
![不少名人明星都是九記的捧場客。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/22e2e90324bcd327ae19694fdae862bc/2023-02/5_0_51.png)
![不少名人明星都是九記的捧場客,(左)陳奕迅,(右)李彩華。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/b6646c8dd82fc36823a2961207586660/2023-02/6_0_39.png)
![不少名人明星都是九記的捧場客,(右)余文樂。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/3e092b5b6b983046dafb53aa011d6852/2023-02/7_0_47.png)
![不少名人明星都是九記的捧場客,(左)關之琳。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/997b5b87496b3eb21944959d99a02243/2023-02/8_0_36.png)
![不少名人明星都是九記的捧場客,(右)任賢齊。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/51ed170473ae5dc69b309c6887efd9e4/2023-02/9_0_14.png)
![疫情前九記每日都大排長龍。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/01c49356d59feb99659a0b16e7b7db7e/2023-02/10_0_21.png)
![疫情期間九記一度休業。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/d2260376c3439c4ff1aa0e1bdbb576fa/2023-02/11_0_23.png)
![全面通關後再度復常。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/b6d48fbd23af62b70d6fb770080a7dc0/2023-02/12_28.png)
![晚上8時仍有人龍。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/cd61761b1fc057da4fa5498ff8f4387e/2023-02/13_18.png)
![不過近日有內地女遊客在小紅書控訴,九記有 3 點令她大失所望。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/66b44ef9a69a493dc4ec98b1dd92b009/2023-02/%E7%84%97%E8%B1%AC%E6%8E%92%E9%A3%AF_0.png)
![第一宗罪 食物質素差](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/98f301d1c04f036d771df5010d90c076/2023-02/15_33.png)
![事主形容九記牛腩的細粉麵底 「口感很粗糙」。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/779fb4761656ea163114f7dce577048d/2023-02/16_34.png)
![指粗麵「直接是鹼水面」、「離譜」、「敷衍的美食態度」。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/66c497d6956de6e4130771a8c3f662a6/2023-02/%E7%84%97%E8%B1%AC%E6%8E%92%E9%A3%AF%20%281%29.png)
![第二宗罪 價錢太貴](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/c728dbf063dc63f701da03e7f7b90511/2023-02/18_22.png)
![九記牛腩設最低消費, 每位港幣65元。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/2f17bf706c97df580803de3a9ceab91b/2023-02/19_23.png)
![事主點了一杯可樂要$16, 一杯檸檬茶要$26, 「關鍵是口感一般哦,也不知道 兌了多少杯水。」](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/7f71da9d66cfb6aa2cfefb085d5d9816/2023-02/20_22.png)
![第三宗罪 整體用餐體驗差](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/30c5a0b29b258b93a0fc24dd4937aa89/2023-02/21_0_6.png)
![事主控訴九記的座位超級擠,「筷子要打架的那種」。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/57714043522538ae31ee70d96d5dabb2/2023-02/22_0_1.png)
![事主亦嫌九記的位置不方便, 「下了地鐵需要七繞八繞,走很遠」 然後又要排長隊。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/1d6eb233c7ad3e583b08c79d3dbc76af/2023-02/23_0_0.png)
![總結整個體驗, 事主勸同胞「香港網紅店九記牛腩千萬別去」。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/c16a6d472b1c07fda88ab8e820674310/2023-02/24_0_1.png)
![不少網民留言附和事主。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/d32570d303e25863a27141a2a9db9372/2023-02/25_0_1.png)
![不少網民留言附和事主。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/69441d2b492482b51c66ebd4ada46dca/2023-02/26_0_1.png)
![不少網民留言附和事主。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/39d50f4a825eab906e16ea057e1c6d1e/2023-02/27_0_1.png)
![不少網民留言附和事主。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/0118225179c387ab6f38de645be9609f/2023-02/28_0_1.png)
![網民指九記對待老顧客或者本地人的態度會好很多。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/e0bfccb11602eb9ca358b07fd56e1a02/2023-02/29_18.png)
![網民批評九記。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/4f433f68eb8246b39751bea30b73fd63/2023-02/30_17.png)
![網民批評九記。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/99510425140ef0e21ccde6498ccd40a9/2023-02/31_18.png)
----
《星島頭條》APP經已推出最新版本,請立即更新,瀏覽更精彩內容:https://bit.ly/3yLrg
最新回應