牛黄解毒片/银翘解毒片可治感冒喉咙痛?忽略1事恐伤肝肾 中医拆解成分/功效/禁忌
2024-06-19 00:00
牛黄解毒片及银翘解毒片是常见中成药,被视为有清热解毒作用,是不少人居家傍身的药物。一旦有热气、牙肉肿痛、感冒等不适症状,就会服用。这两种中成药有何分别?能否纾缓感冒、喉咙痛等不适症状?注册中医师吕兆升接受《星岛头条》访问,讲解这两种药物的成分、功效、用途及禁忌。他提醒,服用时若忽略一大要点,恐伤肝肾。
牛黄解毒片/银翘解毒片有何分别?可治感冒喉咙痛?
注册中医师吕兆升接受《星岛头条》访问,指这两种中成药均具有清热解毒的作用。其中牛黄解毒片主要可分为两种,成分有所不同。至于银翘解毒片,则是以清代《温病条辨》中的银翘散作为基本,演变而成的中成药。
牛黄解毒片 VS 银翘解毒片 成分/功效/用途⬇⬇⬇
![牛黄解毒片](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/11f348702fd478a1732559e682b856bd/2024-01/chinesemedic_A01.png)
![牛黄解毒片主要分为两种](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/602bc63c90cf3168e1abb537d005016d/2024-01/chinesemedic_A02.png)
![第1种的成分包括牛黄、雄黄、石膏、大黄、黄芩、桔梗、冰片及甘草。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/72fd2f402c19964e82a84921ffea83d5/2024-01/chinesemedic_A03.png)
![另一种称为「北京牛黄解毒片」,较为普遍买到。](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/28d94fd9f78300fcab5bbe694961e656/2024-01/chinesemedic_A04.png)
![剔除了较强毒性的成分雄黄,再加入其他药材](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/a4937118eb3f0fa188ebec8d8803b3f4/2024-01/chinesemedic_A05.png)
![具清热解毒之效,用于火热内盛引致的症状](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/c0c597f130b5c04514e3a38f58d96c5c/2024-01/chinesemedic_A06.png)
![例如咽喉肿痛](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/f731b6ffe05a00b3020be85bb7bc6358/2024-01/chinesemedic_A07.png)
![口舌生疮](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/e2a05db5c87baed870d5490329e76526/2024-01/chinesemedic_A08.png)
![牙龈肿痛](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/93e2995f19f01d3a6e3a34cea4f3fb83/2024-01/chinesemedic_A09.png)
![皮肤疮肿](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/e05a9faba651d16fd0834abfe20af8a5/2024-01/chinesemedic_A10.png)
![口臭便秘](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/5d0a5e18e8ec41a20fce82a3fbdb89a1/2024-01/chinesemedic_A11.png)
![银翘解毒片](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/29732430b9d566f237c4b50bfac5bfcc/2024-01/chinesemedic_A12.png)
![从清代《温病条辨》中的银翘散演变而成](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/a1df4a36ab5e977621e0ca86be2ba329/2024-01/chinesemedic_A13.png)
![主要有效成分:金银花、连翘、淡豆豉、牛蒡子、薄荷、荆芥等](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/98e91727ed7cc0532ebe799db980a289/2024-01/chinesemedic_A14.png)
![功效是疏风解表、清热解毒,可用于风热感冒引起的症状](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/434d7dcb00547c4aab95dee60749c6e5/2024-01/chinesemedic_A15.png)
![包括咽喉肿痛](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/5bfb887596005f63e5e768327e814631/2024-01/chinesemedic_A16.png)
![头痛目赤](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/6558513b6c481c9a91bad9ed0b364de5/2024-01/chinesemedic_A17.png)
![发热口乾](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/0de0e027db1cb9b6986b729ac24ef718/2024-01/chinesemedic_A18.png)
![咳嗽流涕](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/fea1c619d7a5d822d1f66c2e4c290423/2024-01/chinesemedic_A19.png)
牛黄解毒片:
- 第一种的成分为牛黄、雄黄、石膏、大黄、黄芩、桔梗、冰片及甘草。
- 另一种是普遍于药房可买得到的「北京牛黄解毒片」,当中具有较强毒性的雄黄被剔除,然后加入多种清热解毒的中药以成方。
- 功效及用途:清热解毒。用于火热内盛引致的咽喉肿痛、口舌生疮、牙龈肿痛、皮肤疮肿、口臭便秘等症状。
银翘解毒片:
- 主要有效成分:金银花、连翘、淡豆豉、牛蒡子、薄荷、荆芥、桔梗、淡竹叶及甘草。
- 功效及用途:疏风解表、清热解毒。用于风热感冒引起的咽喉肿痛、头痛目赤、发热口乾、咳嗽流涕等症状。
甚么人适合服用牛黄解毒片或银翘解毒片?
吕兆升医师提醒,牛黄解毒片与银翘解毒片虽同具清热解毒疗效,其特性及适合人群却有颇大差异:
牛黄解毒片及银翘解毒片不是人人适合服用?
甚么人适合服用?
- 牛黄解毒片:苦寒性味较重,清热力度较强,较适合时常进食辛辣炙煿食物,或素体阳热偏盛人士,出现热毒症状时服用。
- 银翘解毒片:解表力较强而清热力稍逊,较为适合治疗感染风热邪毒后所出现的温热症状。
2类人不宜服用
吕医师指,牛黄解毒片、银翘解毒片均属性质苦寒。故此,以下人士不适宜服用,或服用时必须询问中医师意见:
- 体质虚寒阳气不足、脾胃功能较差者。
- 常见症状为:畏寒肢冷、小便清长、易大便溏泄、面色苍白、纳差不耐生冷(编按:吃生冷食物易不适)、阳事不兴(编按:阳萎)、宫冷不孕者。
牛黄解毒片/银翘解毒片服用禁忌 长期服用有何影响?
此外,吕医师又提醒,服用牛黄解毒片及银翘解毒片之前,须留意以下禁忌:
牛黄解毒片及银翘解毒片服用禁忌:
- 两者均不宜与其他清热解毒药物或食物同服,以免伤及人体阳气。
- 牛黄解毒片有更多的禁忌:因含有大黄,服后容易腹泻。如服后腹部冷痛不止,则需停服,孕妇或月经期间妇女亦禁服;不宜长期服用,因方内雄黄、大黄均有毒性,长期服用必然影响肝肾功能,故服用前应询问注册中医师。
天然食物可取代清热中药吗?
吕兆升医师指出,大多数蔬菜水果都具有清热的功用。因此,平日多吃水果及蔬菜,多喝水,并尽量保持每天大便,就可减少内热形成,毋须时常服食中药清热。
延伸阅读:流感高峰期吃甚么好?中医解构银翘散小柴胡汤中成药功效
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/5acd4e7a3210d9475cc7d0144f992b8f/2024-01/CM_A01.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/fb637c132138d151037c21f6bbef587d/2024-01/CM_A02.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/cc5396efa492626dd887036ff15e53af/2024-01/CM_A03.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/86dd9520b42566f65c066136b6835a56/2024-01/CM_A04.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/050f6499208cbcfcdb636d470384d11b/2024-01/CM_A05.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/9ea5782b64e38f906814873052562f4b/2024-01/CM_A06.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/b65b2409d4ab40fd2f11dbe9a218b423/2024-01/CM_A07.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/389c488f6a9e44bd2ad369ef6e572772/2024-01/CM_A08.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/632091c119fee017e2441d5c29f54468/2024-01/CM_A09.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/f63b3075c32cace27358c7afd5348640/2024-01/CM_A10.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/0c20d8c2b89c9dde168eeecd47d97a01/2024-01/CM_A11.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/a433c769d25bbe2f550093f5efe66bbc/2024-01/CM_A12.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/01f43211a09360f898de198eac6b1fbe/2024-01/CM_A13.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/0c6c974bb9363db74ef5bf3549004863/2024-01/CM_A14.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/8acb3d27ec369175cc8ce5ea23fffb7c/2024-01/CM_A15.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/36e369859e6eb04d1841a0d0cd360b67/2024-01/CM_A16.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/9513e0ce39f516f9d707b9c67620b785/2024-01/CM_A19.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/ae92b9755ae670cbb35683b59404b086/2024-01/CM_A20.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/a72eb8550f3f4c2a5c2fda50affa8f01/2024-01/CM_A21.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/1522375ffe61cdbed56ee92aa163666b/2024-01/CM_A22.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/ee421c79456307b4426a15776bd6b20a/2024-01/CM_A23.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/3b3fc7ec47aae7278925f48d344cd791/2024-01/CM_A24.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/40425487d8c78d39990dc3f8744c3aea/2024-01/CM_A25.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/4fe780c90a990b9953df5db3f360e464/2024-01/CM_A26.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/25c351aa058b9f73e447425600287d7a/2024-01/CM_A27.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/9d8c57a9367d3b36331e154fed55ee80/2024-01/CM_A28.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/221614951654f44b36525308a783f7ee/2024-01/CM_A29.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/d3c98b427c9936b336f24d568a17e4a3/2024-01/CM_A30.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/b4d142f83f07995d37cead3ff5aed601/2024-01/CM_A31.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/c28563d0817798503929d7ef62db20a9/2024-01/CM_A32.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/46b3e41f7ae2d067853e214fec138501/2024-01/CM_A33.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/7b32576de7fcf2a68111705bf8f4a87d/2024-01/CM_A34.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/87e1d388b8a7ad9232cf364d7fd05ca2/2024-01/CM_A35.png)
![](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/fb91e3408df09a1e7bb76ffc56c9fc36/2024-01/CM_A36.png)
延伸阅读:北杏止咳化痰但有毒?中医教分辨3种杏仁
![如何分辨3种杏仁?](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/e8057323f8f55dbba91561eb4f5180ba/2023-11/ALMOND_A10_0.png)
![南杏(Sweet Almonds)](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/98bc8074defdb41c432147f558534caa/2023-11/ALMOND_A11_0.png)
![又称甜杏仁,其外观大而扁](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/62a99074311044d103befbec03d47b01/2023-11/ALMOND_A13_0.png)
![性平,有润肺、润肠通便功效,尤其适合肺气虚弱人士饮用](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/53541dd5e3efe904b229eea5b9f92305/2023-11/ALMOND_A14_0.png)
![感冒未清者、容易反覆腹泻者都不适合食用](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/7339d4627253772db78d85f21eab1d97/2023-11/ALMOND_A15_0.png)
![北杏(Bitter Almonds)](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/4e07a05a5e85a01abb5a9deba0eccb9b/2023-11/ALMOND_A16_0.png)
![又称苦杏仁,外观小而厚](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/88491ce8fd371dcb0efb2255ac6a8102/2023-11/ALMOND_A17_0.png)
![主要为入药用途,味苦,有少毒,可袪痰止咳、平喘及润肠](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/63b9d24e11c2abb407cfef80fbe61b72/2023-11/ALMOND_A18_0.png)
![切忌服用生或未经处理的北杏](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/3366fd2e87c9c8f22cd48ded2753c909/2023-11/ALMOND_A19_0.png)
![坊间出售的南北杏一般已经去皮制熟,且已去除含最多毒素部分;如购入生北杏,先用沸水彻底煮熟才能食用](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/418b77d030cb8756b83e3ed41130c731/2023-11/ALMOND_A20_0.png)
![坚果杏仁(Almonds)](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/ad0124c22f8a1ccc0a625981c083da25/2023-11/ALMOND_A21_0.png)
![又称巴旦杏](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/efc1132d74ca83c86f66191063b5d771/2023-11/ALMOND_A22_0.png)
![属性平和,有润肺及润肠的功效,多作为坚果零食或食材之用](https://image.hkhl.hk/f/1024p0/0x0/100/none/ac5de3185f04873a05c1d98467e07639/2023-11/ALMOND_A23_0.png)
记者:陈思雅
---
相关文章:
记性差夜尿多宜吃六味地黄丸?片仔癀可治瘀伤?中医拆解成分/功效/禁忌 附选购贴士
最新回应